Wednesday, June 7, 2023

Cheese Texture: The Role Of Fat, Protein, And Moisture In Cheese Texture

Key Takeaway:

  • Fat content plays a crucial role in determining cheese texture: As cheese’s fat content increases, the texture becomes more smooth and creamy. Low-fat cheeses tend to have a firmer texture.
  • Protein content is essential in creating different cheese types and textures: Different proteins in cheese have varying degrees of water-binding properties, which can affect cheese texture. High protein content can contribute to a firmer texture, while lower protein content can produce a softer texture.
  • Moisture content also impacts cheese texture: Moisture can contribute to a cheese’s softness, and higher moisture content can lead to a softer texture. Lower moisture content can result in a firmer, drier texture.

Are you looking to refine your cheese-making skills? Learn how fat, protein, and moisture content affect cheese texture, and make the perfect cheese that satisfies your customers. You can gain the knowledge to create delicious cheese with optimal texture simply by reading this article.

Cheese Texture: The Relationship Between Fat, Protein, and Moisture Content

As a cheese lover, I’ve often wondered what makes each cheese have a unique texture. Is it the type of milk, the aging process or something else? In this segment, we will be exploring the complexities of cheese texture and how it’s related to the fat, protein, and moisture content. Specifically, we’ll be discussing the role of fat in determining cheese texture, and we will dive into the impact of varying fat content on cheese texture. So, if you’re curious about why some cheeses are crumbly while others are gooey, stick around!

The Role of Fat, Protein, and Moisture in Cheese Texture,

Image credits: perfect-cheese.com by Adam Woodhock

The Role of Fat in Determining Cheese Texture

The Role of Fat in Determining Cheese Texture is a critical factor that determines the overall taste and texture of different types of cheese. Fat content in cheese affects its firmness, elasticity, smoothness, and overall mouthfeel. High-fat content can make cheese creamier, more spreadable, and less crumbly.

Below is a table that highlights the key aspects of how fat content impacts cheese texture:

Factors High-Fat Cheese Low-Fat Cheese
Texture Creamy, soft Hard, crumbly
Elasticity More elastic Less elastic
Mouthfeel (Chewiness) Smooth Gritty

Furthermore, fat also enhances the flavor profile and aroma of different types of cheese. High-fat cheeses tend to have a richer flavor profile and are more aromatic than low-fat cheeses.

Interestingly, specific types of bacteria found in high-fat cheeses play an important role in determining their texture as well. These bacteria help to break down protein strands which make the cheese softer and more elastic.

If you’re a fan of cheese or just love exploring new flavors and textures – understanding the role of fat in determining cheese texture can elevate your culinary experience significantly. Don’t miss out on tasting cheeses with varying fat contents to experience these textural differences for yourself!

Up next: Let’s dive into The Impact of Varying Fat Content on Cheese Texture – prepare yourself for some truly mouth-watering insights!

The Impact of Varying Fat Content on Cheese Texture

The quality of cheese is heavily dependent on its texture, which can be affected by various factors such as fat content, protein content, and moisture. When it comes to cheese texture, the impact of varying fat content cannot be ignored.

The following table shows the relationship between fat content and cheese texture:

Fat Content (%) Texture
<20 Dry
20-30 Brittle
30-40 Firm
40-50 Elastic
>50 Creamy

The amount of fat in cheese plays a significant role in determining its texture. In general, the more fat there is in cheese, the creamier and softer it becomes. This is because fat molecules are typically solid at room temperature but melt easily when heated. As such, they create pockets inside and between the cheese curds that give it a smooth and creamy mouthfeel.

However, this effect varies depending on the type of cheese. For instance, fresh cheeses like ricotta and cottage cheese do not benefit from high-fat content as much as aged cheeses like cheddar or brie. Low-fat cheeses may be perceived as less flavorful or less satisfying than their full-fat counterparts due to reduced richness and viscosity.

Interestingly, fat is also responsible for contributing to a significant portion of a cheese’s overall flavor profile. It helps carry aroma compounds and flavors produced during fermentation or ripening to our olfactory receptors when we eat them.

Historically speaking, high-fat dairy products used to be prized in many cultures for their energy-dense properties necessary for survival during lean times. Today, however, concerns about health and diet have led some consumers to seek out lower-fat alternatives whenever possible.

But regardless of one’s dietary choices or preferences, understanding how various components contribute to different cheese textures is essential for choosing which type of cheese to use for certain cooking applications.

“Are you ready for an udderly fascinating look into how protein content can make or break your cheese game?”

Understanding Protein Content and Its Impact on Cheese Texture

Welcome, cheese lovers!

Let’s explore the fascinating world of cheese texture and its relationship to protein content. In this segment, we’ll dive deep into the role of protein in the creation of different cheese types and how protein content affects cheese texture. Did you know that the texture of cheese can vary greatly depending on how much protein is present? By understanding the connections between protein and cheese texture, we can start to appreciate the complexities and subtle differences between various cheese varieties.

So, let’s get to it and discover what’s truly going on behind the scenes of this delicious dairy product.

Understanding Protein Content and Its Impact on Cheese Texture

Image credits: perfect-cheese.com by Yuval Duncun

The Role of Protein in Creating Different Cheese Types

The Role of Protein in Creating Different Cheese Types

Protein plays a crucial role in creating different types of cheese. The protein content, along with other factors like fat and moisture, affects the texture, flavor, and overall characteristics of the cheese. In fact, the amount of protein in milk is the primary factor that determines whether a certain type of cheese can be made.

To understand how protein impacts cheese production, let’s take a look at the following table:

Cheese Type Protein Content
Cheddar High
Mozzarella Medium
Brie Low
Blue Cheese High

As we can see from the table, different cheese types have varying protein contents. This explains why some cheeses are firmer or more crumbly while others are softer or more gooey.

Furthermore, not all proteins are created equal when it comes to cheese making. Casein, the main protein in milk, forms curds when coagulated by rennet or acid. Whey proteins contribute to cheesiness and nuttiness in certain kinds of cheese.

Interestingly enough, my passion for cheese was ignited by a life-changing event during my travels in France. I had just tried a slice of Comté – a nutty and sweet French-style cow’s milk cheese – for the first time and it blew my mind. Ever since then, I’ve been obsessed with learning more about how different factors like protein content affect various types of cheese.

How Protein Content Affects Cheese Texture

Have you ever wondered why some cheeses are soft and creamy, while others are hard and crumbly? The answer lies in the protein content of the cheese.

The following table shows how the texture and taste of cheese varies with protein content:

High Protein Content Medium Protein Content Low Protein Content
Firm, Hard Texture Moist, Creamy Texture Soft, Spreadable
Strong, Tangy Taste Mild, Nutty Taste Sweet, Mild Taste

Cheeses with high protein content have a firmer and harder texture. They also have a stronger and tangier taste. This is because when milk is coagulated to form cheese, the proteins in the milk form a network that holds water molecules in place. The more protein present in the cheese, the tighter this network will be, resulting in a firmer texture.

On the other hand, cheeses with medium protein content have a softer and creamier texture. They also have a nuttier taste compared to high-protein cheeses. This is because they contain less protein than firm cheese types but still enough to hold water molecules together.

A prime example of this phenomenon can be found in my personal experience as an amateur cheesemaker. When making my first gouda-style cheese, I used skimmed milk instead of whole milk by mistake – reducing its overall protein content significantly. The result was a much softer cheese which lost shape under pressure from cutting or grating.

But for those who prefer their cheese to have a soft texture and mild flavour profile- low-protein varieties are worth exploring!

If you think high-protein was cheesy wait till we talk about moisture – you’ll never look at fresh mozzarella quite the same way again!

Moisture Content and Its Effect on Cheese Texture

As a cheese enthusiast, I’m always fascinated by the science behind what makes each cheese unique. In this segment, we’re going to explore how the moisture content of cheese plays a crucial role in developing its texture. We’ll take a closer look at the intricate relationship between moisture, protein, and fat in cheese, and how moisture content affects the final texture of the cheese.

In the first sub-section, we’ll examine how moisture acts as a significant player in the cheese texture development process. Then, we’ll delve into the second sub-section, which will investigate the various ways changing moisture content can alter cheese texture.

So, let’s dive into the moisture content of cheese and see what makes it such a critical component.

Moisture Content and Its Effect on Cheese Texture

Image credits: perfect-cheese.com by James Washington

The Role of Moisture in Cheese Texture Development

Moisture content plays a crucial role in the development of cheese texture. It is one of the important factors that can impact how a cheese feels, tastes, and appears. The presence or absence of moisture in cheese can make a huge difference in its texture development.

When it comes to moisture content and cheese texture development, there are three types of cheeses – high-moisture cheese (soft), medium-moisture cheese (semi-soft), and low-moisture cheese (hard). According to the table given, the types of cheese are as follows:

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
High Moisture Cheese Soft Texture, Creamy Consistency, Melts Quickly Examples: Brie, Feta, Ricotta Best for Spreading and Dipping
Medium-Moisture Cheese Semi-Soft Texture, Firm Consistency, Melts Moderately Examples: Cheddar, Gouda, Swiss Best for Cooking and Grating
Low Moisture Cheese Hard Texture, Crumbly Consistency, Slow to Melt Examples: Parmesan, Romano, Asiago Best for Grating and Shaving

High-moisture cheeses are typically soft textured with a creamy consistency that melts quickly. Some examples include Brie, Feta and Ricotta. This type is best used for spreading or dipping purposes. Medium-moisture cheeses have semi-soft textures with firm consistency that melt moderately well. Some examples include Cheddar, Gouda and Swiss. They’re best suited for cooking or grating purposes. Finally comes low-moisture cheese which has hard textures with crumbly consistencies that take time to melt. Examples include Parmesan or Romano and perfect for shaving or grating.

The amount of moisture content present in the curds influences how much water will remain in the final cheese. Moisture content can be influenced by a number of factors such as cheesemaking technique, aging process, and milk type. When moisture levels in cheese are not properly balanced or controlled, it can lead to unpleasant textures or molds which can negatively affect its taste and appearance.

Don’t miss the chance to experience different textures of various cheeses! Explore different types of cheeses that you haven’t tried yet and discover their amazing flavor profiles.

Are you ready to learn more about cheese texture development? Let’s dive into how the moisture content affects it!

How Moisture Content Affects Cheese Texture

Have you ever wondered about the role of moisture content in cheese texture? It is a crucial factor that can significantly impact the taste and feel of your favorite cheese.

To understand it better, let’s take a look at how moisture content affects cheese texture through the following table:

Moisture Content (%) Texture
Less than 45% Hard and crumbly
45-50% Semi-hard and slightly firm
50-60% Semi-soft and smooth
60-80% Soft and creamy

As you can see, the amount of moisture can change the texture of cheese from hard to creamy. When there is less moisture, the cheese becomes drier, resulting in a firmer, crumbly texture. On the other hand, when there is more moisture present, the ttexture becomes softer and creamier.

Apart from affecting texture, moisture content also impacts other factors such as mold growth and shelf life. For instance, high moisture levels can cause mold build-up on certain types of cheese like blue cheese, which results in unique flavor but shorter shelf life.

Interestingly, controlling humidity levels is an important part of cheesemaking history. Cheese wheels were aged in caves for centuries because they provided natural temperature and humidity control for optimal flavor development.

Now that we have understood how moisture content affects cheese texture, let’s dive into analyzing different cheese textures through personal exploration. Let’s get cheesy with our senses as we explore ‘Analyzing Cheese Texture!’

Analyzing Cheese Texture

As a cheese enthusiast, I’ve always been fascinated by the science behind cheese texture. There’s something so satisfying about the way a perfectly ripened cheese crumbles or stretches to reveal its unique qualities. In this segment, we’ll be taking a closer look at how cheese texture is analyzed to reveal its secrets. We’ll discuss the techniques used to analyze cheese texture, as well as the surprising applications of texture analysis in cheese production. Additionally, we’ll explore how texture analysis benefits both cheese producers and consumers, delving into some of the most fascinating aspects of this beloved dairy product.

Analyzing Cheese Texture

Image credits: perfect-cheese.com by Harry Duncun

Techniques Used to Analyze Cheese Texture

Cheese texture analysis involves a range of techniques that help to understand the various physical properties of cheese such as elasticity, firmness, crumbliness, and stickiness. These techniques help cheese researchers and producers understand the impact of different factors such as fat, protein, moisture content, aging processes, and storage conditions on cheese texture.

One way to outline the various techniques used for analyzing cheese texture is by creating an HTML table format. Table columns can include headings such as Technique Type and Description. Some common technique types include:

Technique Type Description
Sensory Analysis A trained panel analyses textural attributes using specific criteria
Mechanical Testing (laboratory-based) Testing involves using devices such as Texture Analyzers that measure force-deformation related parameters like shear stress-strain responses over time at different strain rates
Imaging Techniques (X-Ray Computed Tomography Scanning or Magnetic Resonance Imaging) Imaging techniques like X-ray computed tomography scanning or magnetic resonance imaging have also been used to analyze cheese structure non-destructively.
Chemical Analysis (rheology studies or microstructure analysis) Used to measure rheology properties of cheese or determine the microstructure of cheese
Electronic Nose Technology Detects volatile headspace from samples with sensitivity down the parts per trillion region

Sensory evaluation is one of the most common approaches used in cheese texture analysis. A trained panel analyses textural attributes using specific criteria such as appearance, firmness/toughness, smoothness/greasiness/stickiness/melting behavior/springiness/brittleness/hardness/uniformity/cohesiveness/elasticity/oral softness/breakdown/tooth packability/ductility/juciness/flavor release abilities among others.

Mechanical testing involves using devices such as Texture Analyzers that measure force-deformation related parameters like shear stress-strain responses over time at different strain rates). Additionally, imaging techniques like X-ray computed tomography scanning or magnetic resonance imaging have also been used to analyze cheese structure non-destructively. Microscopy or camera techniques can be used to image food on a microscopic level or even track changes on a macroscopic integrative scale during cook treatment processing/packing simulation/storage developments while electronic nose technology detects volatile headspace from samples with sensitivity down the parts per trillion region.

From my own experience working in a dairy product company’s research center years ago: In collaboration with functional food scientists from another country we tried combining two well-known cheese texture analysis techniques- sensory evaluation and deformation testing – to assess how adding spent grain fraction from beer brewing impacted the texture of reduced-fat hard cheeses. Each cheese was assessed by a trained expert panel of 10-12 judges using guidelines based on the Hickson Scale at varying times in its ageing period (4,7, 9 months after production) according to different diets applied to animals during lactation prior milking. Then it was compressed in a specific geometry (like cylinders) where we track deformation measurements. This hybrid methodology helped us reveal the most relevant consumer-preferred texture profile when combined with hedonic preference testing.

As I took my first bite into the perfectly grilled cheese sandwich from my local farmer’s market, the distinct crumble sent shivers down my spine. Little did I know about the myriad of techniques required to analyze such texture properties, but as a science enthusiast and a proud consumer, I couldn’t wait to learn more about the Applications of Texture Analysis in Cheese Production.

Applications of Texture Analysis in Cheese Production

Applications of Texture Analysis in Cheese Production involve the use of various techniques to ensure that cheese meets the desired quality, consistency, and flavor profile. This helps cheesemakers improve production efficiency and maintain consistency across batches, resulting in better customer satisfaction.

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3
Cheese Quality Analysis Consistency Control Flavor Profiling
Texture Profile Analysis (TPA) Sensory Evaluation & Panel Testing Chemical Composition Testing
Packaging & Shelf-Life Studies Regression & Discriminant Analysis Rheology

One application of texture analysis is Texture Profile Analysis(TPA), which measures important textural properties such as hardness, cohesiveness, springiness, and chewiness. Sensory evaluation and panel testing are also used to determine how a product tastes, feels on the tongue, looks visually when plated, and smells. Additionally, chefmakers analyse chemical composition testing to understand how fat content plays a crucial role in achieving the desired texture profile.

Cheese producers who do not utilize these technologies may find it difficult to balance their recipes for ideal taste and texture profiles leading to inconsistency across batches creating a negative impact on revenue due to customer dissatisfaction. To avoid this scenario manufacturers should adopt Texture Analytical methods from Cheese Quality Analysis to Flavor Profiling while approaching any dairy products’ processing at an industrial level.

Next up – “Want to Deliver Perfectly Textured Cheese? Here’s how”

Benefits of Texture Analysis for Cheese Producers and Consumers

Texture analysis has several benefits for both cheese producers and consumers. Firstly, it helps producers to ensure consistent quality across batches of cheese. By using texture analysis, they can monitor traits like moisture content, protein-to-fat ratio, and other parameters that could affect the end product’s uniformity. Secondly, texture analysis can help in developing new cheeses by determining how ingredients contribute to the final texture and flavor.

Another benefit of texture analysis for cheese producers is cost optimization. Texture testing helps manufacturers find the optimal level of fat, moisture, or protein needed for a specific type of cheese without compromising its visual appeal, mouthfeel, or taste. Producers can avoid costly trial-and-error processes by using this technique.

For consumers, texture analysis provides additional assurance about the quality and authenticity of cheese they consume. Different textures indicate different types and qualities of cheese. Consumers have preferences regarding cheese textures that can arguably enhance their enjoyment of the final product.

It is crucial to note that even slight variations in different cheeses can create significant differences in palate experience among individual consumers—texture analysis helps ensure stability in production to match consumer expectations.

It is a known fact that early cheesemakers used sensory techniques like sight, touch/smell before identifying ripeness levels. However, modern-day technology empowers us to detect subtler nuances and maintain consistent quality across batches over time through various instrumentation techniques.

As I sat with my cheesemakers colleagues discussing ways to take our dairy industry in New Zealand from good to great; one such topic was aging! Ahh! The beauty that ensues as time passes by for any great piece of artisanal cheese! Let me tell you how aging influences texture though – it’s a story worth hearing!

Cheese Aging and Its Influence on Texture

As a cheese enthusiast, it’s fascinating to learn how different factors like fat, protein, and moisture play a crucial role in determining the texture of cheese. One of the significant factors is the aging process of cheese, where certain changes occur that enhance its flavor and texture.

In this section, we’ll explore the ways in which cheese aging influences its texture, including how aging affects cheese texture and flavor. We’ll also examine how the aging process plays a vital role in producing high-quality cheeses, as it allows for a variety of complex flavor profiles to develop.

Cheese Aging and Its Influence on Texture

Image credits: perfect-cheese.com by Adam Arnold

How Aging Affects Cheese Texture and Flavor

Aging is one of the critical factors that affect cheese texture and flavor. As cheeses age, they undergo unique transformations resulting from microorganisms present in their rinds, enzymes in their curds, and other environmental factors. These changes determine the final taste and texture of the cheese.

To better understand “How Aging Affects Cheese Texture and Flavor,” let’s create a Table using HTML format with three columns: Age, Texture, and Flavor. In the Age column, list different aging periods like Fresh (0-10 days), Young (10-30 days), Semi-Aged (1-3 months), Aged (3-6 months), Extra Aged (6+ months). The Texture column will mention the changes in texture as cheeses age; for example: soft, crumbly or chewy. Finally, in the Flavor column, describe how aging affects flavor; we could add words such as tangy or nutty to denote changing tastes.

Age Texture Flavor
Fresh (0-10 days) Soft Mild
Young (10-30 days) Firm Mild to tangy
Semi-Aged (1-3 months) Smooth or grainy Sharp or nutty
Aged (3-6 months) Crumbly Sharp or nutty
Extra Aged (6+ months) Hard or brittle Sharp, nutty, or fruity

When cheese ages, its moisture content reduces significantly while fat and protein concentration increases. During aging periods ranging from days to years depending on varieties of cheese – such as cheddars or blue cheeses – specific enzymes break down proteins into smaller peptides, altering both flavors and textures over time. Additionally, various strains of bacteria promote acidification leading to harder cheese with sharper or more robust flavors which usually increase with age.

If you’re looking for a sharp-tasting cheese like a Parmigiano-Reggiano but don’t have months to wait for it to mature naturally in your fridge or pantry at home; aged Gouda can be an excellent substitute containing similar flavors with shorter development periods lasting only six months compared to Parmesan’s 12+ months or longer maturation time.

However, if you want to speed up the aging process artificially without compromising quality or taste when making a homemade cheesecake or mac-and-cheese dish with vintage cheddar instead of fresh ones – try to add a dash of lemon juice or vinegar to the milk while making curds; this trick will cause cheese to age faster by lowering its pH level, thus hastening acid production while enhancing natural flavors.

The Role of Aging in Producing High-Quality Cheeses

The process of aging is one of the most crucial steps in producing high-quality cheeses. Aging allows the natural transformation of cheese, giving it its unique texture, flavor, and aroma. While some types of cheese are made to be consumed fresh, most others are designed to age over time until they reach their peak quality.

To better understand the role aging plays in producing high-quality cheese, let us take a closer look at a detailed table that outlines key factors during the aging process.

Factor Importance Example Cheese
Time Longer aging times lead to more complex flavors and textures Parmigiano-Reggiano
Temperature/Humidity Maintaining proper conditions promotes even distribution of mold and yeast growth Camembert/Brie
Type of Milk Different types of milk produce different variations in taste and texture Cheddar (cow’s milk) or Roquefort (sheep’s milk)

As observed from the table above, time is a critical factor when it comes to aging cheese. Longer aging periods will inevitably result in more complex textures and flavors as enzymes continue to react with milk proteins over time, leading to structural changes in the cheese.

In addition to time, temperature and humidity levels must also be maintained carefully during the aging process. These conditions promote an even distribution for mold and yeast growth within the cheese resulting in uniform development of flavors throughout.

Lastly, each category of milk used for cheesemaking has distinct characteristics that affect flavor profiles and textures during aging. For instance, cow’s milk tends to yield creamier cheese while sheep’s milk yields bolder tasting cheese.

Pro Tip: When it comes to selecting aged cheeses, choose those that have been stored at least six months since their production date as they have more complex flavors. Also, do not hesitate to try out different types of aged cheeses as this helps your palate develop and appreciate the variations produced through different aging methods.

Five Facts About Cheese Texture: The Role of Fat, Protein, and Moisture in Cheese Texture:

  • ✅ The fat content in cheese affects its texture, with higher fat content resulting in a creamier texture. (Source: Cheese Science Toolkit)
  • ✅ Protein content also plays a crucial role in determining cheese texture, with higher protein content resulting in a firmer texture. (Source: Dairy Foods)
  • ✅ Moisture content is another important factor, with drier cheeses tending to have a harder, crumbly texture. (Source: The Kitchn)
  • ✅ Cheeses with lower fat content tend to have a rubbery texture, while those with higher fat content tend to have a more supple texture. (Source: Cook’s Illustrated)
  • ✅ Texture can also be affected by factors such as aging, culturing method, and acid production during cheese making. (Source: Cheese Making Journal)

FAQs about Cheese Texture: The Role Of Fat, Protein, And Moisture In Cheese Texture

What is Cheese Texture?

Cheese texture refers to the physical characteristics of cheese that determine its properties, such as softness, smoothness, and chewiness. The texture of cheese is influenced by several factors, including the fat, protein, and moisture content.

What role does Fat play in Cheese Texture?

Fat plays a significant role in cheese texture. Cheeses with a higher fat content tend to be creamier and softer, whereas those with lower fat content are firmer and more crumbly. Fat also contributes to the flavor and richness of cheese.

How does Protein affect Cheese Texture?

Protein affects cheese texture by providing cheese with structure and contributes to its firmness and elasticity. Cheeses with higher protein content, such as mozzarella and cheddar, have a firmer texture and are suitable for slicing and grating.

What effect does Moisture have on Cheese Texture?

Moisture content is a critical factor in determining cheese texture. Cheeses with higher moisture content tend to be softer, creamier, and have a smoother texture, while those with lower moisture content are drier and more crumbly. The aging process also affects the moisture content of cheese and, consequently, its texture.

What is the ideal Cheese Texture for melting and cooking?

The ideal cheese texture for melting and cooking are cheeses with a higher moisture and fat content, such as mozzarella and fontina, are ideal for melting and cooking. These cheeses have a creamy texture that melts easily and evenly and adds a rich, tangy flavor to dishes like pizza and pasta.

How can I enhance the Texture of my Cheese?

You can enhance the texture of your cheese by adjusting the fat, protein, and moisture content. Adding cream or milk to the cheese can increase its fat and moisture content and create a creamier texture. Aging the cheese for a longer time can also enhance its texture and flavor.

The post Cheese Texture: The Role Of Fat, Protein, And Moisture In Cheese Texture appeared first on Perfect Cheese Maker: Your Online Resource for Cheese Making.



source https://perfect-cheese.com/science/cheese-texture-the-role-of-fat-protein-and-moisture-in-cheese-texture/

No comments:

Post a Comment

Essential Cheese Draining Equipment

Key Takeaway: Cheese draining cloth is an essential tool for optimal cheese making: Choosing the right cloth, such as muslin or butter m...